It’s also for Compost. But I’ll get to that in a minute.
First let me say this: Cookie Monster has always been a monster after my own heart. Growing up, wondering whether monsters actually lived in closets, I secretly wished that big, blue, furry soul mate was lurking in mine with a package of Mr. Christie’s under his arm. As if a package of Mr. Chrisite’s would last five seconds in his lovable paws.
My general rule of thumb with cookies is that they must have chocolate chips in them. Anything beyond that is gravy. Or hot fudge. Using the word gravy in a post about cookies feels wrong.
My problem with cookies, as I’m sure many of you have experienced, is mastering consistency. The best cookie is one five minutes out of the oven with a crispy outer shell and a delectably chewy inside. But so often they either end up like hockey pucks (not enough butter) or flat, bubbly amoeba-like blobs (too much butter – yes, there is such a thing). Thankfully, the goddess of all things devilish has come up with a perfect combination of sinful simplicity.
There’s no pussy footing around with Nigella’s cookies. The recipe only makes 14, despite calling for ingredients that could make twice that many. This is because she asks that you to use a quarter-cup measure to make your cookies, not some pansy teaspoon. This is a latte-sized cookie. I can’t stand running out of cookie half-way through the joe.
This recipe is the likely only one I will ever use for chip-based cookies from now until the end of time, in part because it allows for spontaneous cookie baking. In other words, the eggs are supposed to be cold. This is from her book, Kitchen, with some additional commentary on my part. She lists all measurements in weight, which is good in a way but mostly a pain in the ass until you break down and spend $20 on a scale. I converted them, but they’re all over the place in terms of Metric/Imperial.
Chocolate Chip Cookies
- 10 tbsp (150g) soft unsalted butter
- 3/4 cup packed (125g) soft light brown sugar
- 110 ml (100g) caster sugar
- 2 tsp vanilla extract
- 1 egg, fridge-cold
- 1 egg yolk, fridge-cold
- 2 cups (300g) flour
- 1/2 tsp baking soda
- 1 x 326g packet milk chocolate morsels or some other such thing
Melt the butter and let it cool a bit. Put the brown and white sugars into a bowl, pour the slightly cooled butter over them and beat. Beat in vanilla, the cold egg, the cold egg yolk until your mixture is light and creamy. Slowly mix in the flour and baking soda until just blended. Fold in the chocolate bits.
Scoop cookie dough into a quarter-cup measure or 60 ml ice cream scoop and drop 8 cm apart onto a large baking sheet that’s lined with parchment paper.* You’ll probably need to do two batches, keeping the bowl in the fridge while the first batch bakes.
Bake 15-17 min in a 338°F (170°C) or until edges are lightly toasted. I usually take them out when they look like an Irish tan (ie. still pretty white) because I always tend to over-bake cookies. Allow them to cool on the baking sheet for five minutes before you transfer them to a wire rack, if they make it that far.
A Variation
This is where the compost part comes in. I can’t remember the context but sometime ago a friend of mine suggested I try making compost cookies. I had no idea what she was talking about. My next-door neighbour had just been telling me about the compost tea her husband was making for the garden. So naturally I thought, compost tea with a compost cookie… for the tomatoes?
But no. A compost cookie is, surprisingly, something you eat. Why anyone would want to eat something named after rotting plant matter is beyond me. But the concept was a winner: take any treats you’re trying to forget you own, b
ash them with the frustration of someone who can’t resist temptation and throw them into a batch of cookie dough.
Make sure there’s something for everyone. Some salty, some sweet. And while this may seem like an opportunity to combine all the great things Cadbury, Nestle, and Lays have ever made, I advise you to use restraint. Think of it like putting together the perfect outfit for a cocktail party (0r in my world, a trip to the free play-zone at the mall): you don’t want to overdo the accessories.
As I was Googling around for some combo suggestions, I noticed a lot of people complaining that their you-know-what cookies were flattening out like they’d lost all hope. I knew exactly what to do. Rather, Nigella did. I took a quick perusal of the island (cupboard) of misfit snacks and finalized my cookie combo. Pretzels, chocolate wafer cookies, chocolate chips, peanut butter chips and a Wunderbar. The finished product was the perfect balance of all things snackable, perfectly plump, crispy around the edge and chewy in the middle.
Oh, and I’m changing the name. They’re called Kitchen Sinkers, as in anything but.
*Just in case you are ignorant like me, waxed paper is NOT the same as parchment paper. It is a very bad idea to make this mistake, especially if your smoke detectors are hard-wired into the house and three feet above your jumping capabilities.
Tags: chocolate chip cookies, compost cookies, cookie monster, NIgella Lawson